SeeShell unstable - hardly any usable


#1

Hi, I downloaded SeeShell to evaluate its feasability for a bigger automation.
It’s concept and approach sparked our interest but unfortunately we need to conclude that SeeShell is all but “rock solid”.

  1. test scripts arbitrarily stop their execution - they run endlessly. It can be stopped from main window then

  2. Simple operations like “Type” (aka Send Keys) does not work reliably:
    e.g. command Type “{WINKEY}chrome https://abcdef…{ENTER}”. Only works 1 out of 10 cases.
    Either only the start menue opens, sometimes chrome starts but only has a fraction of the URL line in the address bar. ~1 out of 20 cases it is working fully.
    => It looks like a timing issue with the sendkey buffer to us. That is really basic stuff…

  3. EXTRACT does not work reliably at all.
    E.g error message “no green rectangle found”-> But it is definetely there in the image;
    Testing the recognition with the image editor shows very ( I mean really very) odd matches all around the screen. These matches have not even the same color as the pattern. Also increasing confidence level does not solve it…

  4. The built in chromium browser dies. It usually works once immediately after startup. Then after the first script running chromium dies.

As this is a bunch of not obviously related but very fundamental issues I am wondering if there is a stable version available for us to test where at least basics would work to evaluate?

best regards


#2

Hello, thanks for the open feedback. This is a long list of issues, so it seems something is going wrong and SeeShell is not working as it usually does: So I have a few more questions:

  • Can you please describe what kind of tasks you want to automate?
  • Do you use SeeShell for Web Automation, SeeShell for Desktop automation or both?
  • What version of Windows?

#3

Hello,
many thanks for the very fast reply. Sure thing, here are more informations:

  • What kind of tasks we intend to automate: -> Transferring of (ticket) data from one web application to another web application
  • We have tried both, “Desktop” first as it sounded more promising (can do both), then SeeShell for Web. The latter works slightly better admitted (application has only died twice until now and recocnition seems more successful)
  • Currently testing on Win10 (1803)

Best regards,


#4

Thanks for the info. Actually… for this use case I recommend that you use our Kantu software. Reasons:

  • With storeText, storeValue and sourceExtract Kantu is better at extracting info from websites (web scraping)

  • In addition to selenium ide commands, it supports now the same visual automation as SeeShell, including relative clicks. (However, it has no recording wizard for image commands. The visual commands are created within the Kantu editor.)

  • One drawback is that it does not have a COM API. But it has a command line interface, so it can be scripted as well.


#5

Thank you very much for giving this (workaround) recommendation.

Just experimenting with Kantu… unfortunately first tests show more problems, this time with XClick (required as “click” does not work/fire up the js event on the web app:

-> “kantu-xy-host.exe has stopped working”; will open seperate thread under kantu

BR


#6

-> “kantu-xy-host.exe has stopped working”; will open seperate thread under kantu

Very strange… => Yes, please open a new post for this and add the following information:

  • Which operating system? (Win 10, macOS Mojave, Linux Ubuntu 18.04,… etc)
  • Is there any anti-virus software running?
  • Is there any other automation software running?
  • Does the crash happen always or “only” sometimes?
  • Can you test on a second system and see if you get the same issue there?

#7

I find the same thing. If it was stable it would be (almost) great.
But how can we be expected to pay for something that works erratically?


#8

btw the “green rectangle not found” error only appears to me if I try to set the timeout in the script


#9

Stay tuned for the upcoming new updates. PRO customers have already access to the the new beta version.